As impeachment barrels onward, Democrats have preemptively turned their ire from House Republicans towards Senate Republicans, starting with Mitch McConnell....Keep reading...
Legal analysts speculate on impeachment: Could Clarence Thomas lead the trial?
One of the Supreme Court’s most conservative justices could preside over President Donald Trump’s impeachment trial — if it comes to that.
At least, that was the assessment of constitutional law professors Josh Blackman and Seth Barrett Tillman. In a piece first published on the legal blog Balkinization on Sunday, the legal scholars argued that Clarence Thomas could be the one who oversees the trial that could lead to Trump’s removal.
According to Blackman and Barrett Tillman, the vice president presides over most impeachments. But when it’s the president who is facing removal, that job falls to the Supreme Court’s chief justice — in this case, John Roberts.
But what if Roberts were to pass away or otherwise become incapable of conducting his duties? While the Constitution does not address the question directly, Blackman and Barrett Tillman claim to have an answer.
“By all accounts, Chief Justice Roberts is in good health,” they noted. “But in the unlikely scenario that Roberts is unavailable, Clarence Thomas, the most senior Associate Justice, would preside.”
The pair explains that “the Constitution refers to a Chief Justice and ‘judges of the Supreme Court’—not ‘Associate Justices.’ The Judiciary Act of 1789, and not the Constitution, introduced the term Associate Justice,” they added.
This, they say, “suggests that the First Congress intended that the other judges of the Supreme Court could serve as substitutes for the Chief Justice.”
In other words…
The authors go on to cite legislation from 1948 that states: “Whenever the Chief Justice is unable to perform the duties of his office or the office is vacant, his powers and duties shall devolve upon the associate justice next in precedence who is able to act, until such disability is removed or another Chief Justice is appointed and duly qualified.”
“In other words,” Blackman and Barrett Tillman conclude, “if the Chief Justice cannot perform his duties, then the associate justice with the most seniority — known as the Senior Associate Justice — serves as acting Chief Justice.” And having served since 1991, Justice Thomas is the most senior figure on the Supreme Court.
Nominated by then-President George H.W. Bush in 1991 to fill the vacancy left by Justice Thurgood Marshall, Thomas was hit by sexual harassment allegations early in his confirmation hearings. His accuser was a former subordinate named Anita Hill, who many felt had credibility issues, according to National Review.
For his part, Thomas denied any wrongdoing and characterized efforts to derail his appointment as “a high-tech lynching,” according to The Washington Post. He was later confirmed to the high court, and has remained a strong conservative voice on the bench ever since.
Still, at 64 years old, Chief Justice Roberts remains healthy as a horse compared to other justices, like the 86-year-old Ruth Bader Ginsburg, whose health struggles have kept her home from work more in recent months than ever before. But if Thomas does get the chance to take Roberts’ place and preside over impeachment, President Trump surely wouldn’t be complaining.
JOIN THE MOVEMENT
Add your best email address below to start receiving news alerts.
President Donald Trump’s appointment of William Barr to United States Attorney General, according to The Irish Times’s Suzanne Lynch, “may be...Keep reading...
On Friday, Rep. Karen Bass (D-CA) appeared on MSNBC’s The Last Word to discuss President Donald Trump’s impeachment. Bass is a...Keep reading...
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), a top-tier 2020 contender for the Democrats, retracted an endorsement just one day after he first...Keep reading...
Republicans on the House Judiciary Committee — the committee that is putting together the articles of impeachment against President Donald...Keep reading...
Hunter Biden, the son of former vice president and current 2020 contender Joe Biden, is back making headlines, and they...Keep reading...